| 356 | 0 | 878 |
| 下载次数 | 被引频次 | 阅读次数 |
尽管地方政策试点创新的驱动因素和扩散机制已得到广泛研究,但试点创新成功的内在逻辑仍未被充分阐释。本研究从政府注意力和国家能力的理论视角出发,揭示了地方政府在试点创新中取得成功的路径,强调了“主观意图”(条件A)与“客观资源”(条件B)协同作用的重要性。在专业化水平较高的政策创新领域,例如数字化改革相关的试点创新中,地方政府不仅需要具备基础的国家能力,还需拥有强大的专项国家能力,即国家计算能力。通过浙江省数字化政策试点创新的实证分析,结果表明,仅依靠推动数字化改革的政府注意力分配(主观意图)不足以确保政策创新的成功,唯有同时具备注意力分配和国家计算能力,才能显著提升地方政府数字化改革试点创新的绩效。本研究为理解地方政府试点创新的成功机制提供了新的理论视角,并为推动数字化改革的政策实践提供了重要启示。
Abstract:Although the driving forces and diffusion mechanisms of local policy pilot innovation have been widely studied, the intrinsic logic underlying the success of pilot innovation remains insufficiently elucidated. This paper, from the theoretical perspectives of government attention and state capacity, reveals the paths through which local governments achieve success in pilot innovation, emphasizing the importance of the synergy between “subjective intention”(condition A) and “objective resources”(condition B). In specialized policy innovation fields, such as pilot innovation related to digital reform, local governments not only need to possess basic state capacity but also require strong specialized state capacity, particularly computing capacity. Based on an empirical analysis of digital policy pilot innovation in Zhejiang Province, the results show that relying solely on government attention allocation for driving digital reform(subjective intention) is insufficient to ensure the success of policy innovation. Only when both attention allocation and computing capacity are present can they significantly enhance the performance of local government digital reform pilot innovation. This paper provides a new theoretical perspective for understanding the success mechanisms of local pilot innovation and offers some insights for promoting policy practices in digital reform.
[1] 郁建兴,黄飚.当代中国地方政府创新的新进展——兼论纵向政府间关系的重构[J].政治学研究,2017(5):88-103.
[2] 韩博天,石磊.中国经济腾飞中的分级制政策试验[J].开放时代,2008(5):31-51.
[3] ZHU X,ZHAO H.Experimentalist Governance with Interactive Central-Local Relations:Making New Pension Policies in China[J].Policy Studies Journal,2021,49(1):13-36.
[4] 朱旭峰,张超.央地间官员流动、信息优势与政策试点——以国家可持续发展议程创新示范区为例[J].公共行政评论,2020(4):130-146.
[5] 唐世平,高岭,李立,等.国家能力:走出理论荒野[J].学术月刊,2022(11):68-83.
[6] WANG S,YANG D Y.Policy Experimentation in China:The Political Economy of Policy Learning[J].Journal of Political Economy,2025,133(7):2180-2228.
[7] 谭海波,范梓腾,杜运周.技术管理能力、注意力分配与地方政府网站建设——一项基于TOE框架的组态分析[J].管理世界,2019(9):81-94.
[8] 练宏.注意力分配——基于跨学科视角的理论述评[J].社会学研究,2015(4):215-241.
[9] SIMON H A.A Comment on “The Science of Public Administration”[J].Public Administration Review,1947,7(3):200-203.
[10] BAUMGARTNER F R,JONES B D.Agendas and Instability in American Politics[M].Chicago:University of Chicago Press,2009:577-588.
[11] HEBERER T,TRAPPEL R.Evaluation Processes,Local Cadres’ Behavior and Local Development Processes[J].Journal of Contemporary China,2013,22(84):1048-1066.
[12] O’BRIEN K J,LI L.Selective Policy Implementation in Rural China[J].Comparative Politics,1999,31(2):167-186.
[13] 周雪光.基层政府间的“共谋现象”——一个政府行为的制度逻辑[J].社会学研究,2008(6):1-21.
[14] 周黎安,刘冲,厉行,等.“层层加码”与官员激励[J].世界经济文汇,2015(1):1-15.
[15] 李立,吴春来,蔡瑜曾.“合作应对”何以替代“上下共谋”——对春镇基层政策执行的过程追踪[J].社会学评论,2023(4):74-95.
[16] MANN M.The Autonomous Power of the State:Its Origins,Mechanisms and Results[J].European Journal of Sociology,1984,25(2):185-213.
[17] 李路路,李汉林.中国的单位组织:资源、权力与交换[M].杭州:浙江人民出版社,2000:5-24.
[18] 马鸿佳,王春蕾,李卅立,等.数据驱动如何提升数字平台生态系统竞争优势?——基于数据网络效应视角[J].管理世界,2024(12):170-185.
[19] 孟天广,郑思尧.国家治理的信息理论:信息政治学的理论视角[J].政治学研究,2023(6):117-130.
[20] EVANS P,RAUCH J E.Bureaucracy and Growth:A Cross-National Analysis of the Effects of “Weberian”State Structures on Economic Growth[J].American Sociological Review,1999,64(5):748-765.
[21] ANDREWS M,PRITCHETT L,WOOLCOCK M.Building State Capability:Evidence,Analysis,Action[M].Oxford:Oxford University Press,2017:9-28.
(1)本文中的国家能力特指地方政府能力或次国家能力。
基本信息:
DOI:10.20158/j.cnki.ylggzl.2025.04.004
中图分类号:D630
引用信息:
[1]李立,黄圳.国家计算能力、注意力分配与试点创新——来自浙江省的证据[J].岳麓公共治理,2025,4(04):51-63.DOI:10.20158/j.cnki.ylggzl.2025.04.004.
基金信息:
国家社会科学基金青年项目:算法赋能背景下纵向政府间控制权调适机制与优化配置研究(24CZZ041); 中央高校基本科研业务费项目:算法赋能背景下纵向政府间控制权调适机制与优化配置研究(CCNU24XJ049)
2025-07-04
2025-07-04
2025-07-04